I was hesitant to spend a bit more on a pen tray, but the PURE & ANALOG walnut tray is worth every penny. The rich tones of the wood are even more beautiful in person, and the tray is perfectly sized. It's obvious that this product was made with care, and the attention to detail is what sets it apart from other pen trays. I love the way it looks on my desk, and it's a great conversation starter when I have guests over.